diff --git a/app/Console/Commands/TriggerPendingApprovalMails.php b/app/Console/Commands/TriggerPendingApprovalMails.php
index 97d2781..480c987 100644
--- a/app/Console/Commands/TriggerPendingApprovalMails.php
+++ b/app/Console/Commands/TriggerPendingApprovalMails.php
@@ -42,7 +42,6 @@ class TriggerPendingApprovalMails extends Command
 
     public $wfId;
 
-
     public function handle()
     {
         $this->info('Approval mail job started');
@@ -74,165 +73,163 @@ class TriggerPendingApprovalMails extends Command
         });
 
         if ($records->isEmpty()) {
-            $this->info('No pending approvals');
-            return;
-        }
+            $this->info('No characteristics pending approvals');
+        }else{
+            $grouped = $records->groupBy(function ($item) {
+                $this->wfId = $item->work_flow_id;
+                return $item->plant_id . '|' . $item->machine_id . '|' . $item->aufnr . '|' . $item->work_flow_id;
+            });
 
-        $grouped = $records->groupBy(function ($item) {
-            $this->wfId = $item->work_flow_id;
-            return $item->plant_id . '|' . $item->machine_id . '|' . $item->aufnr . '|' . $item->work_flow_id;
-        });
+            $pendingApprovers = RequestCharacteristic::where('work_flow_id', $this->wfId)->latest()->first();
 
-        $pendingApprovers = RequestCharacteristic::where('work_flow_id', $this->wfId)->latest()->first();
-
-        $this->info($pendingApprovers->approver_status1, $pendingApprovers->approver_status2);
+            $this->info($pendingApprovers->approver_status1, $pendingApprovers->approver_status2);
 
 
-        $approverNameFromMaster = null;
-        if ($pendingApprovers && $pendingApprovers->characteristic_approver_master_id) {
-            $approverNameFromMaster = CharacteristicApproverMaster::find($pendingApprovers->characteristic_approver_master_id);
-        }
-
-        $rows = [];
-
-        foreach ($grouped as $groupRecords) {
-
-            $first = $groupRecords->first();
-
-            $approver = CharacteristicApproverMaster::where('plant_id', $first->plant_id)
-                ->where('machine_id', $first->machine_id)
-                ->where('id', $first->characteristic_approver_master_id)
-                ->first();
-
-            if (!$approver) {
-                continue;
+            $approverNameFromMaster = null;
+            if ($pendingApprovers && $pendingApprovers->characteristic_approver_master_id) {
+                $approverNameFromMaster = CharacteristicApproverMaster::find($pendingApprovers->characteristic_approver_master_id);
             }
 
-            $characteristics = $groupRecords->map(fn ($r) => [
-                'work_flow_id'        => $r->work_flow_id,
-                'characteristic_name' => $r->characteristic_name,
-                'current_value'       => $r->current_value,
-                'update_value'        => $r->update_value,
-            ])->toArray();
+            $rows = [];
 
-            $level    = null;
-            $mail     = null;
-            $name     = null;
-            $updateData = [];
-            $now = Carbon::now();
+            foreach ($grouped as $groupRecords) {
 
-            // --- FIRST MAIL ---
-            if (is_null($first->mail_status)){
-                $level = 1;
-                $mail = $approver->mail1;
-                $name = $approver->name1;
+                $first = $groupRecords->first();
 
-                $updateData['mail_status'] = 'Sent';
+                $approver = CharacteristicApproverMaster::where('plant_id', $first->plant_id)
+                    ->where('machine_id', $first->machine_id)
+                    ->where('id', $first->characteristic_approver_master_id)
+                    ->first();
 
-                if ($approver->duration1 > 0)
-                {
-
-                    $duration = number_format((float)$approver->duration1, 2, '.', '');
-                    [$hours, $minutes] = explode('.', $duration);
-
-                    $totalMinutes = ((int)$hours * 60) + (int)$minutes;
-
-                    $updateData['trigger_at'] = $now
-                        ->copy()
-                        ->addMinutes($totalMinutes)
-                        ->startOfMinute();
+                if (!$approver) {
+                    continue;
                 }
-                else
-                {
+
+                $characteristics = $groupRecords->map(fn ($r) => [
+                    'work_flow_id'        => $r->work_flow_id,
+                    'characteristic_name' => $r->characteristic_name,
+                    'current_value'       => $r->current_value,
+                    'update_value'        => $r->update_value,
+                ])->toArray();
+
+                $level    = null;
+                $mail     = null;
+                $name     = null;
+                $updateData = [];
+                $now = Carbon::now();
+
+                // --- FIRST MAIL ---
+                if (is_null($first->mail_status)){
+                    $level = 1;
+                    $mail = $approver->mail1;
+                    $name = $approver->name1;
+
+                    $updateData['mail_status'] = 'Sent';
+
+                    if ($approver->duration1 > 0)
+                    {
+
+                        $duration = number_format((float)$approver->duration1, 2, '.', '');
+                        [$hours, $minutes] = explode('.', $duration);
+
+                        $totalMinutes = ((int)$hours * 60) + (int)$minutes;
+
+                        $updateData['trigger_at'] = $now
+                            ->copy()
+                            ->addMinutes($totalMinutes)
+                            ->startOfMinute();
+                    }
+                    else
+                    {
+                        $updateData['trigger_at'] = null;
+                    }
+                }
+
+                // --- SECOND MAIL ---
+                elseif (
+                    $first->mail_status == 'Sent' &&
+                    (is_null($first->approver_status1) || $first->approver_status1 == 'Hold') &&
+                    $first->trigger_at &&
+                    \Carbon\Carbon::parse($first->trigger_at)->lte($now)
+                ) {
+
+                    $this->info(
+                        "mail_status: {$first->mail_status}, ".
+                        "approver_status1: {$first->approver_status1}, ".
+                        "trigger_at: {$first->trigger_at}, ".
+                        "now: {$now}"
+                    );
+
+                    $level = 2;
+                    $mail = $approver->mail2;
+                    $name = $approver->name2;
+
+                    if ($approver->duration2 > 0) {
+
+                        $duration = number_format((float)$approver->duration2, 2, '.', '');
+                        [$hours, $minutes] = explode('.', $duration);
+
+                        $totalMinutes = ((int)$hours * 60) + (int)$minutes;
+
+                        $updateData['trigger_at'] = $now->copy()->addMinutes($totalMinutes);
+                    } else {
+                        $updateData['trigger_at'] = null;
+                    }
+
+                    $updateData['mail_status'] = 'Sent-Mail2';
+                }
+
+                // --- THIRD MAIL ---
+                elseif (
+                    $first->mail_status == 'Sent-Mail2' &&
+                    (is_null($first->approver_status1) || $first->approver_status1 == 'Hold') &&
+                    (is_null($first->approver_status2) || $first->approver_status2 == 'Hold') &&
+                    $first->trigger_at &&
+                    \Carbon\Carbon::parse($first->trigger_at)->lte($now)
+                ) {
+                    $level = 3;
+                    $mail = $approver->mail3;
+                    $name = $approver->name3;
+
                     $updateData['trigger_at'] = null;
+                    $updateData['mail_status'] = 'Sent-Mail3';
                 }
-            }
 
-            // --- SECOND MAIL ---
-            elseif (
-                $first->mail_status == 'Sent' &&
-                (is_null($first->approver_status1) || $first->approver_status1 == 'Hold') &&
-                $first->trigger_at &&
-                \Carbon\Carbon::parse($first->trigger_at)->lte($now)
-            ) {
+                if (!$level || !$mail) {
+                    continue;
+                }
 
-                $this->info(
-                    "mail_status: {$first->mail_status}, ".
-                    "approver_status1: {$first->approver_status1}, ".
-                    "trigger_at: {$first->trigger_at}, ".
-                    "now: {$now}"
+                $pdfPath = 'uploads/LaserDocs/' . $first->work_flow_id . '.pdf';
+
+                $subjectLine = 'Characteristic Approval Mail';
+
+                Mail::to($mail)->send(
+                    new CharacteristicApprovalMail(
+                        $first,
+                        $name,
+                        $level,
+                        $pdfPath,
+                        $pendingApprovers,
+                        $approverNameFromMaster,
+                        $subjectLine,
+                        $characteristics
+                    )
                 );
 
-                $level = 2;
-                $mail = $approver->mail2;
-                $name = $approver->name2;
+                RequestCharacteristic::whereIn('id', $groupRecords->pluck('id'))
+                    ->update($updateData);
 
-                if ($approver->duration2 > 0) {
-
-                    $duration = number_format((float)$approver->duration2, 2, '.', '');
-                    [$hours, $minutes] = explode('.', $duration);
-
-                    $totalMinutes = ((int)$hours * 60) + (int)$minutes;
-
-                    $updateData['trigger_at'] = $now->copy()->addMinutes($totalMinutes);
-                } else {
-                    $updateData['trigger_at'] = null;
-                }
-
-                $updateData['mail_status'] = 'Sent-Mail2';
+                $rows[] = [
+                    $first->id,
+                    $first->plant_id,
+                    $first->machine_id,
+                    "Level $level",
+                    $mail,
+                    'SENT'
+                ];
             }
-
-            // --- THIRD MAIL ---
-            elseif (
-                $first->mail_status == 'Sent-Mail2' &&
-                (is_null($first->approver_status1) || $first->approver_status1 == 'Hold') &&
-                (is_null($first->approver_status2) || $first->approver_status2 == 'Hold') &&
-                $first->trigger_at &&
-                \Carbon\Carbon::parse($first->trigger_at)->lte($now)
-            ) {
-                $level = 3;
-                $mail = $approver->mail3;
-                $name = $approver->name3;
-
-                $updateData['trigger_at'] = null;
-                $updateData['mail_status'] = 'Sent-Mail3';
-            }
-
-            if (!$level || !$mail) {
-                continue;
-            }
-
-            $pdfPath = 'uploads/LaserDocs/' . $first->work_flow_id . '.pdf';
-
-            $subjectLine = 'Characteristic Approval Mail';
-
-            Mail::to($mail)->send(
-                new CharacteristicApprovalMail(
-                    $first,
-                    $name,
-                    $level,
-                    $pdfPath,
-                    $pendingApprovers,
-                    $approverNameFromMaster,
-                    $subjectLine,
-                    $characteristics
-                )
-            );
-
-            RequestCharacteristic::whereIn('id', $groupRecords->pluck('id'))
-                ->update($updateData);
-
-            $rows[] = [
-                $first->id,
-                $first->plant_id,
-                $first->machine_id,
-                "Level $level",
-                $mail,
-                'SENT'
-            ];
         }
 
-
         // .. Quality Mail trigger logic
 
         $qualityRecords = RequestCharacteristic::where(function ($q) {
@@ -382,8 +379,8 @@ class TriggerPendingApprovalMails extends Command
                     $pdfPath,
                     $pendingApprovers,
                     $approverNameFromMaster,
-                    $subjectLine,
-                    $characteristics
+                    $subjectLine
+                    // $characteristics
                 )
             );